top of page

The danger of agreeing too soon

21 hours ago
2 min read

Why good strategy needs disagreement


I often work with leaders seeking consensus on a key strategic choice, within their senior leadership team or board. I remind them that while consensus at the end of the discussion is a goal worth pursuing, consensus during the discussion has serious downsides.

 

We've all heard of the dangers of group-think. But from a strategy point of view the importance of constructive disagreement goes even deeper.

 

Good strategy is disputable

Any good strategy should be 'disputable', as Richard Rumelt puts it in his book Good Strategy / Bad Strategy. Someone should always be able to argue against a good strategy.

 

And this is what people often misunderstand. They think a good strategy should be so clever, thorough and insightful that once stated it's obvious to everyone it's a winner. That's not true. If everyone agrees, you've probably avoided all the hard choices, so your strategy won't be saying no to enough.

 

The best strategies take a stand

The brand voice of Virgin is a good example. When they decided in the 1980s to adopt an informal, somewhat irreverent voice with their customers, it would have been easy to sit in that boardroom and argue against it. Show disrespect to our customers and they'll go elsewhere.

 

A similar story can be seen in Ikea's decision to have only a small number of very large stores. It would have been easy to argue that, like a supermarket, Ikea should expand its number of stores. But that would have undermined the rest of their interlinking manufacturing and distribution strategy.

 

In both examples the strategy takes a stand. You should be able to dispute a good strategy by putting forward counter-arguments. Otherwise, what's the stand you're taking?


Disagree well, then commit

Leaders also need to sit comfortably within a disagreement. Matthew Syed's idea of separating people from ideas is helpful here. People should never feel unsafe during these discussions - psychological safety is vital. But ideas should be fundamentally unsafe until the final decision is made. No good idea arrives fully formed. It's forged in the heat of robust discussion.

 

And once the strategy is set, the senior team and board need to get 100% behind it publicly. Without that kind of consensus, any stand you take is doomed to fail.

 

Invite disagreement while the decision is being made. Then unite completely once it is.


Where does your strategy actually take a stand?

I work one-to-one with senior leaders, helping them build strategies to tackle complex challenges. If you'd like to explore what that could look like for you, you can find out more here.



This post was originally shared with my email list. Want to receive weekly reflections on strategy, leadership and high-stakes decision-making delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up here.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Weekly reflections on strategy and leadership

​

A short weekly email sharing reflections on strategy, leadership and high-stakes decision-making, drawn from my work with senior leaders.

 

(You'll see a thank you message when this form is submitted - if you don't see this message please try clicking 'Sign me up' again.)

I care about your data and privacy. You will be able to unsubscribe at any time.

  • LinkedIn Social Icon

© 2026 Juliet Corbett Consulting Ltd. Company number: 13091128 (England and Wales); VAT number: 407 9520 91; Registered office: 10 Lakes Down, Exeter, EX5 5BD, UK

bottom of page